Trans fats cause more problems for McDonalds...
Trans fats are formed when liquid vegetable oils go through a chemical
process called hydrogenation. Common in a range of food products
biscuits, chips, doughnuts, crackers the hydrogenated
vegetable fat is used by food processors because it is solid at
room temperature and has a longer shelf life.
The Harvard School of Public Health think that 30,000 or more premature
heart disease deaths are caused each year by trans fats from partially
hydrogenated oils in food supplies.
In September 2002, McDonald's issued a statement announcing a significant
reduction of trans fats in its fried menu items french fries,
chicken McNuggets, Filet-O-Fish, Hash Browns and crispy chicken
sandwiches with the introduction of improved cooking oil
in all of its 13,000 restaurants.
The change was supposed to be completed by February 2003. However,
McDonalds encountered operational issues and the oil was not
changed.
An anti-trans
fat group claims that McDonald's deliberately allowed the public
to be misled.
"Based on a document that we have received, McDonald's has
spent a grand total of $457.50 to get the word out to the public
that it has not changed the oil. Meanwhile, it has been reaping
millions of dollars in additional profits from customers who believe
that they are getting the new healthier oil."
Legal
action has forced McDonalds to give effective notice to
the public that the oil was not changed. In fact, McDonalds
is required to spend up to $1.5 million on publishing notices to
ensure that the public knows the status of its trans fat initiative.
If the cost of publishing the notices is less than $1.5 million,
the difference will be donated to the American Heart Association.
McDonalds will also donate $7 million to the American Heart
Association.
In Europe and the US, food makers are under growing pressure from
consumer groups to cut the trans fat content in food products.
Last year Denmark became the first country in the world to ban
trans fats from food products over fears these hydrogenated fats
could contribute to heart disease.
While the European Union has yet to reach a position on the labelling
of trans fats, changes are likely as consumer bodies keep up the
pressure for tougher labelling and call on the industry to use alternatives.
In the US, incoming rules mean that by 2006 food manufacturers
will have to label the trans fat content.
Bruce Holub, a professor of nutritional sciences at Canada's University
of Guelph, thinks that ingesting a daily gram of trans fat over
several years is enough to significantly boost your risk of heart
disease. Professor Holub points out that as few as two crackers
can contain an entire gram of TFA.
Kraft foods said earlier this year that it had launched a trans
fat free version of its iconic Oreo biscuit. The move follows a
court case against Krafts owner Nabisco which attracted
massive media attention in the US - whereby the firm was asked to
remove the biscuits from sale because of the harm trans fats could
cause to children.
The case was later withdrawn because the lawyer who filed the suit
said the publicity surrounding the case accomplished what he set
out to do - create awareness about the dangers of trans fats.
However not all scientists agree about the potential dangers of
trans fats. Dr. Rudolph Riemersma from Edinburgh, UK, points out
that some studies have found a link between trans fats and heart
disease while others have not.
He is particularly critical of 'prospective' studies, which he
says do not prove that a particular food is to blame and that there
may be other common reasons which account for the poor health of
study subjects.
Riemersma also points out that banning trans fats may force manufacturers
to process fats in other ways that may be even more harmful. Professor
Antii Aro from Helsinki, did not find a clear link between trans
fats and heart disease in his study. While he believes that
trans fats are harmful, he thinks that saturated fats are a much
greater concern.
Professor Daan Kromhout from the Netherlands points out that there
is no reason to have trans fats in the diet. He also draws attention
to major flaws in studies that found no adverse health effects related
to trans fats, and concludes that taking all the evidence into account,
the link between trans fats and cardiac deaths is one of the most
consistent in nutritional epidemiology.
A 2002 report from a National Academy of Sciences panel attempted
to set a safe intake level for trans-fatty acids. The report confirmed
previous findings about the relationship of trans-fatty acids and
the risk of heart disease, and concluded with this recommendation:
"The only safe intake of trans-fat is zero."
|